Got the early 70’s Star Trek:The Animated Series on DVD from the library last week. This was an ‘interim’ series done by Filmation from 1973-74, originally intended as a kid’s Saturday am cartoon show but given the hunger at the time for anything/all things Star Trek, actually served to ‘continue on’ the original 60’s series for many fans. I had seen at least a few of these either back then or later in reruns, and had borrowed the set from a friend a few years ago but neglected to watch many of them then.
The show had 22 episodes, which is pretty good considering that the original series only has 79 to begin with (and the third original season had a lot of crappy shows, for that matter). Most of the original cast is here (Kirk/Shatner, Spock/Nimoy, Scotty/Doohan, Uhura/Nichols and Takei/Sulu) save for Chekov/Walter Koenig, who was left out due to budget constraints – but did get to write an episode, The Infinite Vulcan.
One difference (besides being animated instead of live-action) is that the shows are only a half-hour, meaning in practice about 24 min. or so – whereas the original had hour-long episodes. So this constrains the storytelling a bit, but they still did pretty well with what they had. Another is a better variety of weird aliens, architecture and landscapes – animation naturally provides more flexibility in that case, and they used it well.
On balance, the quality is pretty good here. Even though of course Kirk and Spock get the vast majority of the lines – and now after having watched 40+ years of various Star Trek shows enough to think sending the 3-4 most important members of the crew on all the dangerous away missions is STU-PID, guys! – it’s still entertaining. I think besides having most of the original series’ actors, it helped having many of the original writers (or eminently qualified newbies like Larry Niven) handling the scripts, and Dorothy Fontana, one of the key veterans of the original series running the show overall.
Looking at specific episodes, I’d have to say my favorites were the following:
Beyond The Farthest Star – While elements of this plot were used already in an original series 3rd season episode (Day of the Dove) this is better than that one, even if shorter. This story has far more of the sense of wonder and exploration Star Trek is known for, and the alien taking over the Enterprise is more plausible in this story the way it unfolds.
Yesteryear – Here we see some of Spock’s back story and tie in The Guardian from the original series – a great combination.
The Survivor – Despite the increasing proliferation of crew members wearing cheesy handlebar mustaches from this episode onward – the plot is interesting and has a twist or two to boot.
The Magicks of Megas-tu – A favorite recurring theme on Star Trek is ‘ancient aliens visited Earth/other planets of the Federation in primitive times and now we have to deal with how we treated them’ – This idea was also seen in Who Mourns for Adonais? (original series) and even later in the animated series in How Sharper than a Serpent’s Tooth which throws in the oft-seen ‘Star Trek loves to whip out the Shakespeare’ in its title. I’m not going to go into that one, as anyone who’s watched any amount of Star Trek (TV or movies) will be already familiar with THAT tendency….’Magicks’ is also interesting in that the included DVD commentary notes the network said they couldn’t do an episode with ‘god’ in it – so they chose Lucifer instead
The Slaver Weapon – This is the Larry Niven episode, which includes elements of his own books and stories as a plot foundation (Slavers, Kzinti, etc.) and it definitely works well.
The Jihad – This was one I remembered reading from the books Alan Dean Foster did based on the animated series (Star Trek ‘Logs’) and the animated version is unfortunately not as good, because it leaves out some of the dialog (it’s probable that ADF simply ‘wrote more’ as he did the novellas *after* the series aired) and the sequence with the ‘dune buggy’ they use to escape a molten lava volcano here is pretty silly.
If you don’t want to watch the series on TV – you can always read the books referenced above, which should still be around in paperback somewhere – they came out in the early 80s I think?
All in all, it was good and interesting to revisit these. Several of them are definitely up to the best of the original series for sure, even if their stories aren’t as long timewise due to the shorter format.
candybowl